Processing skills pay the most in Melvor Idle 2, because a finished product can sell for far more than the inputs it eats, while gathering skills earn from raw sell values alone, and the live money making ranking shows the current rates.
What the ranking counts
The ranking follows one rule: profit is what the products sell for minus what the inputs would sell for. A gathering action has no inputs, so the Ashen Log from an Ashen Tree is all profit, and that log sells for 212 GP. A processing action is different, because its inputs count as a cost even when you gathered them yourself. Cooking a Raw Whale shows it: the Raw Whale sells for 4,500 GP and the Whale it becomes sells for 6,067 GP, so the recipe is worth only the difference. Inputs that only the shop sells are priced at their GP cost. Some shop items cost another currency, and Blood Essence is one: it costs 50 Slayer Coins and needs Slayer level 75. Blood Essence sells for 1 GP. The ranking has no GP price for a purchase like that, so it falls back to the sell value and flags the row.
Woodcutting, the gathering ladder
Woodcutting gives the clearest gathering ladder, because every tree gives one log and the log’s sell value climbs with the level. A Normal Log sells for 3 GP, while a Willow Log sells for 17 GP and a Teak Log sells for 25 GP. The Magic Tree at level 75 is where logs get serious, because a Magic Log sells for 161 GP. An Ashen Log sells for 212 GP, a Hard Oak Log sells for 248 GP and a Redwood Log sells for 342 GP. The price of a log does not set the order, because the trees take different times. The Redwood Tree gives the dearest log but takes 26 seconds per action, while the Ashen Tree takes 14 seconds for its 212 GP log, which is why the Ashen Tree tops the table. The Hard Oak Tree takes 22 seconds, so it pays less per hour than either of them. Fort Gate sits in the Quests category at Woodcutting level 39 and gives 30 Teak Logs per action over 100 seconds, which is why the table shows it in the middle brackets. Trees at that level give one log per action, which is what makes Fort Gate stand out in the table.
| Level Bracket | Fastest XP Method | Est. XP Rate | Best Profit Method | Est. GP Rate | Calculator Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Levels 1 – 10 | Oak Tree | 7,200 XP/h | Wood Debris | 7,200 GP/h | Train 1 → 10 |
| Levels 11 – 20 | Oak Tree | 7,200 XP/h | Wood Debris | 7,200 GP/h | Train 11 → 20 |
| Levels 21 – 35 | Treant Remains | 15,000 XP/h | Fortress Wall | 24,480 GP/h | Train 21 → 35 |
| Levels 36 – 50 | Warped Cacti | 21,240 XP/h | Fort Gate | 27,000 GP/h | Train 36 → 50 |
| Levels 51 – 60 | Yew Tree | 21,343 XP/h | Fort Gate | 27,000 GP/h | Train 51 → 60 |
| Levels 61 – 75 | Magic Tree | 24,300 XP/h | Magic Tree | 28,980 GP/h | Train 61 → 75 |
| Levels 76 – 90 | Ashen Tree | 31,114 XP/h | Ashen Tree | 54,514 GP/h | Train 76 → 90 |
| Levels 91 – 99 | Ashen Tree | 31,114 XP/h | Ashen Tree | 54,514 GP/h | Train 91 → 99 |
A Hard Oak Log goes into the Air Fury Staff in Runecrafting, which needs 56 Air Rune, 28 Blood Rune, an Unpowered Orb and 1 Hard Oak Log and sells for 2,337 GP. Two Redwood Logs go into the Refined Meteorite Bow in Fletching.
Mining and smelting
Mining pays mostly through Smithing, because ore sells low and bars sell high. A Dragonite Bar sells for 307 GP and takes 1 Dragonite Ore, which sells for 97 GP, plus 12 Coal at 5 GP each. Meteorite Ore from Mining level 75 sells for 89 GP. Smelted with 10 Coal and 1 Golden Stardust, 2 of that ore make a Refined Meteorite Bar that sells for 6,076 GP. Golden Stardust sells for 1,242 GP and comes from the Golden Fallen Star in Mining at level 50, or from the Astrologer in Thieving. The bar then feeds Fletching: a Refined Meteorite Bow needs 3 of those bars, 2 Redwood Logs and a Bowstring, and sells for 21,090 GP at level 96. That bow tops the Fletching table, so one skill’s best row depends on a bar from Smithing, ore from Mining and logs from Woodcutting.
Thieving feeds the artisan skills
Thieving has no fixed product, because every target rolls a loot table with weights. The Ore Stall at level 85 drops Copper Ore, Iron Ore, Coal, Silver Ore, Gold Ore, Mithril Ore, Adamantite Ore, Runite Ore, Dawnsteel Ore and Dragonite Ore. Its Dragonite Ore is the same ore that the Dragonite Bar recipe takes. The Gem Stall at level 92 drops only uncut gems, with Uncut Topaz the commonest and Uncut Jadestone the rarest. The Locked Beast Chest at level 90 in Thieving gives 10 to 20 Elk Hide as common loot. Elk Hide is the input for Elk Leather in Crafting. Elk Leather unlocks at Crafting level 55 and takes 2 Elk Hide and 1 Cowhide for 2 leather that each sell for 141 GP, against 48 GP for each hide. The Locked Bank Chest at level 63 drops Topaz and Silver Bars, and the Astrologer at level 36 drops Stardust. Those three feed the Astral Silver Topaz Amulet, a Crafting recipe at level 18 that takes 2 Silver Bar, 1 Topaz and 1 Stardust and sells for 276 GP.
Crafting at the top of the range
Crafting rows run on hides, gems and bars from other skills. At level 92 the best row is Storm Lynx Leather, which takes 3 Storm Lynx Hide and 1 Cowhide for 2 leather that sell for 518 GP each. Storm Lynx Hide does not come from a gathering skill: it drops from the Storm Lynx monster. Cowhide comes from Thieving, Ranching or Hunting, or you can buy it in the shop.
| Level Bracket | Fastest XP Method | Est. XP Rate | Best Profit Method | Est. GP Rate | Calculator Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Levels 1 – 10 | Basic Small Bird Catcher | 18,000 XP/h | Pack of Vials | 14,400 GP/h | Train 1 → 10 |
| Levels 11 – 20 | Basic Butterfly Kit | 30,600 XP/h | Astral Silver Topaz Amulet | 109,200 GP/h | Train 11 → 20 |
| Levels 21 – 35 | Empty Lantern | 41,400 XP/h | Astral Silver Topaz Amulet | 109,200 GP/h | Train 21 → 35 |
| Levels 36 – 50 | Basic Pitfall Trap | 66,600 XP/h | Astral Silver Topaz Amulet | 109,200 GP/h | Train 36 → 50 |
| Levels 51 – 60 | Basic Large Bird Net | 99,000 XP/h | Elk Leather | 320,400 GP/h | Train 51 → 60 |
| Levels 61 – 75 | Basic Spirit Box | 118,800 XP/h | Elk Leather | 320,400 GP/h | Train 61 → 75 |
| Levels 76 – 90 | Basic Torag Trap | 480,600 XP/h | Torag Leather | 545,400 GP/h | Train 76 → 90 |
| Levels 91 – 99 | Fortified Torag Trap | 671,400 XP/h | Storm Lynx Leather | 1,542,600 GP/h | Train 91 → 99 |
Cooking and the fish behind it
Chicken Sandwich and Whale in Cooking both take 3 seconds per attempt, so what separates them is the sell values. Chicken Sandwich at level 20 takes 1 Bread, 1 Raw Chicken, 1 Lettuce and 1 Onion, and gives 2 sandwiches that sell for 168 GP each. The inputs sell for between 2 and 5 GP each, which is why a cheap recipe can beat a fish you worked hard to catch. Glowing Soup at level 95 takes five different inputs. It takes Soup Base, Raw Glowing Jellyfish, Raw Glowing Squid, Raw Glowfin and Cabbage, and makes 10 soups that sell for 448 GP each. Raw Glowing Squid comes from the Luminous Abyss at Fishing level 93, and Cabbage comes from Farming at level 80. Griffin Steak unlocks at Cooking level 70, but its Raw Griffin Steak comes from the Griffin in Hunting at level 87. It also has a difficulty of 270, so expect failed attempts. The cooking rows in the table below count every attempt as a success, while the live ranking applies a success chance, so use the ranking for Cooking.
| Level Bracket | Fastest XP Method | Est. XP Rate | Best Profit Method | Est. GP Rate | Calculator Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Levels 1 – 10 | Sardine | 10 XP/h | Sardine | 9 GP/h | Train 1 → 10 |
| Levels 11 – 20 | Chicken Sandwich | 38 XP/h | Chicken Sandwich | 322 GP/h | Train 11 → 20 |
| Levels 21 – 35 | Strawberry Cake | 52 XP/h | Chicken Sandwich | 322 GP/h | Train 21 → 35 |
| Levels 36 – 50 | Relief Rations (Meat) | 180 XP/h | Banana Pancake | 413 GP/h | Train 36 → 50 |
| Levels 51 – 60 | Cherry Pie | 203 XP/h | Banana Pancake | 413 GP/h | Train 51 → 60 |
| Levels 61 – 75 | Pumpkin Pie | 350 XP/h | Griffin Steak | 1,578 GP/h | Train 61 → 75 |
| Levels 76 – 90 | Pumpkin Pie | 350 XP/h | Griffin Steak | 1,578 GP/h | Train 76 → 90 |
| Levels 91 – 99 | Whale | 700 XP/h | Glowing Soup | 3,472 GP/h | Train 91 → 99 |
Smithing: pickaxes against bars
Smithing tops the profit tables with pickaxes, and the reason is the finished price. Stoners Pickaxe at level 60 takes a damaged pickaxe, 100 Stone and 50 Adamantite Bar, and sells for 51,680 GP. Essence Imbued Pickaxe at level 85 takes a damaged pickaxe, a Mystify Wand, 500 Pure Essence and 100 Dawnsteel Bar, and sells for 240,417 GP. Both recipes consume a damaged pickaxe, and that item is found by opening a Geode. Plain bar smithing has cheap inputs: the Dragonite Bar recipe takes only ore and Coal.
| Level Bracket | Fastest XP Method | Est. XP Rate | Best Profit Method | Est. GP Rate | Calculator Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Levels 1 – 10 | Copper 2H Sword | 9,000 XP/h | Copper Platelegs | 19,800 GP/h | Train 1 → 10 |
| Levels 11 – 20 | Iron Platebody | 13,200 XP/h | Iron Platelegs | 39,240 GP/h | Train 11 → 20 |
| Levels 21 – 35 | Steel Lantern | 34,800 XP/h | Steel Platebody | 46,286 GP/h | Train 21 → 35 |
| Levels 36 – 50 | Abyssal Bar | 900,000 XP/h | Ironsteel Bar | 61,920 GP/h | Train 36 → 50 |
| Levels 51 – 60 | Abyssal Bar | 900,000 XP/h | Stoners Pickaxe | 8,582,220 GP/h | Train 51 → 60 |
| Levels 61 – 75 | Abyssal Bar | 900,000 XP/h | Stoners Pickaxe | 8,582,220 GP/h | Train 61 → 75 |
| Levels 76 – 90 | Essence Imbued Pickaxe | 900,000 XP/h | Essence Imbued Pickaxe | 18,009,450 GP/h | Train 76 → 90 |
| Levels 91 – 99 | Infernal Pickaxe | 1,500,000 XP/h | Essence Imbued Pickaxe | 18,009,450 GP/h | Train 91 → 99 |
Where a recipe loses money
Turning a valuable bar into a part can lose GP. A Refined Meteorite Javelin Head recipe gives 8 heads that sell for 397 GP each, but it eats a Refined Meteorite Bar worth 6,076 GP. The Dracolith Ravager Amulet takes a Dracolith Ravager Scale worth 356,299 GP, 2 Gold Bar and a Jadestone, and sells for 120,682 GP. The Cul Belra Ring at level 93 takes a Cul Torag Core worth 2,638,244 GP and a Belra Crystal worth 602,095 GP, and sells for 8,150,106 GP. A Super Melee Potion P2-A makes 35 potions that sell for 4 GP each, and it uses 2 Dawnsteel Bar at 127 GP each.
What to do at each bracket
Until level 20, gather and sell logs from the Normal Tree and the Oak Tree, then cook Chicken Sandwich as soon as Cooking reaches level 20. At level 55 add Elk Leather if you have Elk Hide, and at 75 cut Magic Trees. At level 80 move to the Ashen Tree. From level 85 the Ore Stall drops ores that the Dragonite Bar recipe at the same level takes, and from 90 the Locked Beast Chest, Storm Lynx Leather and the Redwood Tree open up. At 92 the Refined Meteorite Bar and the Gem Stall unlock, and the XP table runs on to the cap at level 99.


