Herb seeds in Melvor Idle 2 come from five channels: pickpocketing in Thieving, catching birds and beasts in Hunting, opening Herb Seed Pack I and Herb Seed Pack II from the Agility Arena Reward Shop, opening chests and survey containers, and fighting monsters. Only Barrentoe Herb Seed has a direct GP shop listing, at Farming level 90 for 10,000 GP.
Thieving and Hunting sources
Market Seed Stall at Thieving level 35 drops 1 Penril Herb Seed or 1 Sourweed Herb Seed as common loot. The same Market Seed Stall at level 35 also drops 1 Mantalyme Herb Seed or 1 Nomel Herb Seed. Herbalist at Thieving level 38 drops 1 to 3 of those early herb seeds or 1 to 3 Oxilyme Herb Seed as common loot, plus 1 to 4 Sporlyle Herb Seed as rare loot.
At Thieving level 70, Capital Seed Stall drops 1 Nomel Herb Seed, 1 Oxilyme Herb Seed, or 1 Sporlyle Herb Seed as common loot. Capital Seed Stall at level 70 also drops 1 Larx Herb Seed or 1 Barrentoe Herb Seed as common loot.
In Hunting, Greentail Bird at level 10 rolls 1 Penril Herb Seed or 1 Sourweed Herb Seed, while Bluetail Bird at level 25 rolls 1 Mantalyme Herb Seed. Higher Hunting targets continue the line: Yellowtail Bird at level 40 rolls 1 Nomel Herb Seed, Harpy at level 53 rolls 1 Sporlyle Herb Seed, and Blacktail Bird at level 57 rolls 1 Oxilyme Herb Seed. For the top two seeds in Hunting, Raptor at level 75 and Blood Hawk at level 78 each roll 1 Larx Herb Seed, while Night Raven at level 86 and Belra Torag, Gar Torag, Fin Torag, and Cul Torag from levels 90 to 97 each roll 1 Barrentoe Herb Seed.
| Item | Source | How | Level | Quantity | Chance / cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Penril Herb Seed | Market Seed Stall | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 35 | 1× | 0.70%1 in 143 |
| Penril Herb Seed | Herbalist | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 38 | 1–3× | 1.8%1 in 56 |
| Penril Herb Seed | Greentail Bird | Hunting | Lv. 10 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Penril Herb Seed | Small Survey Findings | Container | — | 1× | 7.7% per open1 in 13 |
| Penril Herb Seed | Herb Seed Pack I | Container | — | 2–4× | 33.3% per open1 in 3 |
| Penril Herb Seed | Hobgolbin | Monster drop | Combat 12 | 2× | 2.3% per kill1 in 44 |
| Penril Herb Seed | Scarecrow | Monster drop | Combat 15 | 1–2× | 4.8% per kill1 in 21 |
| Sourweed Herb Seed | Market Seed Stall | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 35 | 1× | 0.44%1 in 228 |
| Sourweed Herb Seed | Herbalist | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 38 | 1–3× | 1.7%1 in 61 |
| Sourweed Herb Seed | Greentail Bird | Hunting | Lv. 10 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Sourweed Herb Seed | Small Survey Findings | Container | — | 1× | 5.1% per open1 in 20 |
| Sourweed Herb Seed | Harvest Farm Chest | Container | — | 2–4× | 12.8% per open1 in 8 |
| Sourweed Herb Seed | Herb Seed Pack I | Container | — | 2–4× | 26.7% per open1 in 4 |
| Sourweed Herb Seed | Scarecrow | Monster drop | Combat 15 | 1–2× | 3.8% per kill1 in 26 |
| Mantalyme Herb Seed | Market Seed Stall | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 35 | 1× | 0.26%1 in 381 |
| Mantalyme Herb Seed | Herbalist | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 38 | 1–3× | 1.5%1 in 67 |
| Mantalyme Herb Seed | Bluetail Bird | Hunting | Lv. 25 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Mantalyme Herb Seed | Small Survey Findings | Container | — | 1× | 2.6% per open1 in 39 |
| Mantalyme Herb Seed | Harvest Farm Chest | Container | — | 2–4× | 6.4% per open1 in 16 |
| Mantalyme Herb Seed | Herb Seed Pack I | Container | — | 2–4× | 20.0% per open1 in 5 |
| Mantalyme Herb Seed | Jack O Lantern | Monster drop | Combat 21 | 2× | 3.4% per kill1 in 30 |
| Nomel Herb Seed | Market Seed Stall | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 35 | 1× | 0.18%1 in 571 |
| Nomel Herb Seed | Herbalist | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 38 | 1–3× | 1.4%1 in 74 |
| Nomel Herb Seed | Capital Seed Stall | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 70 | 1× | 5.0%1 in 20 |
| Nomel Herb Seed | Yellowtail Bird | Hunting | Lv. 40 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Nomel Herb Seed | Small Survey Findings | Container | — | 1× | 2.6% per open1 in 39 |
| Nomel Herb Seed | Herb Seed Pack I | Container | — | 2–4× | 13.3% per open1 in 8 |
| Nomel Herb Seed | Herb Seed Pack II | Container | — | 10–20× | 33.3% per open1 in 3 |
| Nomel Herb Seed | Carrion Crow | Monster drop | Combat 36 | 1× | 3.5% per kill1 in 29 |
| Nomel Herb Seed | Spirit Stag | Monster drop | Combat 50 | 1× | 4.8% per kill1 in 21 |
| Oxilyme Herb Seed | Herbalist | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 38 | 1–3× | 1.2%1 in 83 |
| Oxilyme Herb Seed | Capital Seed Stall | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 70 | 1× | 5.0%1 in 20 |
| Oxilyme Herb Seed | Blacktail Bird | Hunting | Lv. 57 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Oxilyme Herb Seed | Medium Survey Findings | Container | — | 1× | 5.9% per open1 in 17 |
| Oxilyme Herb Seed | Herb Seed Pack I | Container | — | 2–4× | 6.7% per open1 in 15 |
| Oxilyme Herb Seed | Herb Seed Pack II | Container | — | 10–20× | 26.7% per open1 in 4 |
| Oxilyme Herb Seed | Carrion Crow | Monster drop | Combat 36 | 1–11× | 1.7% per kill1 in 57 |
| Oxilyme Herb Seed | Murkwood Spider | Monster drop | Combat 36 | 1× | 1.7% per kill1 in 58 |
| Sporlyle Herb Seed | Herbalist | Thieving (rare loot) | Lv. 38 | 1–4× | 0.94%1 in 106 |
| Sporlyle Herb Seed | Capital Seed Stall | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 70 | 1× | 3.0%1 in 33 |
| Sporlyle Herb Seed | Harpy | Hunting | Lv. 53 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Sporlyle Herb Seed | Medium Survey Findings | Container | — | 1× | 4.4% per open1 in 23 |
| Sporlyle Herb Seed | Herb Seed Pack II | Container | — | 10–20× | 20.0% per open1 in 5 |
| Sporlyle Herb Seed | Harpy | Monster drop | Combat 52 | 1–3× | 1.1% per kill1 in 93 |
| Larx Herb Seed | Capital Seed Stall | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 70 | 1× | 3.0%1 in 33 |
| Larx Herb Seed | Raptor | Hunting | Lv. 75 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Larx Herb Seed | Blood Hawk | Hunting | Lv. 78 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Larx Herb Seed | Medium Survey Findings | Container | — | 1× | 4.4% per open1 in 23 |
| Larx Herb Seed | Large Survey Findings | Container | — | 1× | 3.7% per open1 in 27 |
| Larx Herb Seed | Herb Seed Pack II | Container | — | 10–20× | 13.3% per open1 in 8 |
| Larx Herb Seed | Wind Drifter | Monster drop | Combat 76 | 1× | 3.8% per kill1 in 26 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Capital Seed Stall | Thieving (common loot) | Lv. 70 | 1× | 2.0%1 in 50 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Belra Torag | Hunting | Lv. 90 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Gar Torag | Hunting | Lv. 92 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Fin Torag | Hunting | Lv. 94 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Cul Torag | Hunting | Lv. 97 | 1× | 20.0%1 in 5 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Night Raven | Hunting | Lv. 86 | 1× | 50.0%1 in 2 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Large Survey Findings | Container | — | 1× | 2.8% per open1 in 36 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Herb Seed Pack II | Container | — | 10–20× | 6.7% per open1 in 15 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Vampire | Monster drop | Combat 79 | 1× | 0.86% per kill1 in 117 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Dark Wizard | Monster drop | Combat 79 | 1× | 2.0% per kill1 in 51 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Dreadspine | Monster drop | Combat 81 | 1× | 2.7% per kill1 in 37 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Nightwing | Monster drop | Combat 79 | 1× | 1.3% per kill1 in 77 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Elder Vampire | Monster drop | Combat 82 | 1× | 2.8% per kill1 in 36 |
| Barrentoe Herb Seed | Barrentoe Herb Seed | Shop | — | 1× | 10,000 GP |
Seed packs, containers, and monster drops
In the Agility Arena Reward Shop, Herb Seed Pack I unlocks at Agility level 35 for 300 Arena Reward Token and yields 2 to 4 seeds per open, while Herb Seed Pack II unlocks at Agility level 80 for 1,350 Arena Reward Token and yields 10 to 20 seeds per open.
| Loot Item | Quantity | Chance (%) | Odds |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 – 4 | 33.33% | 1 in 3 | |
| 2 – 4 | 26.67% | 1 in 4 | |
| 2 – 4 | 20.00% | 1 in 5 | |
| 2 – 4 | 13.33% | 1 in 8 | |
| 2 – 4 | 6.67% | 1 in 15 |
| Loot Item | Quantity | Chance (%) | Odds |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 – 20 | 33.33% | 1 in 3 | |
| 10 – 20 | 26.67% | 1 in 4 | |
| 10 – 20 | 20.00% | 1 in 5 | |
| 10 – 20 | 13.33% | 1 in 8 | |
| 10 – 20 | 6.67% | 1 in 15 |
Hunting survey containers also hold single seeds, from Small Survey Findings for the first four herbs to Medium Survey Findings and Large Survey Findings for the higher tiers, while Harvest Farm Chest rolls 2 to 4 Sourweed Herb Seed or Mantalyme Herb Seed.
Monsters drop herb seeds across combat tiers, from Hobgolbin at combat level 12 and Scarecrow at level 15 up to Carrion Crow at level 36 for 1 to 11 Oxilyme Herb Seed and Vampire, Dark Wizard, Nightwing, Dreadspine, and Elder Vampire at levels 79 to 82 for 1 Barrentoe Herb Seed. In the Farming shop tab, Barrentoe Herb Seed costs 10,000 GP at Farming level 90 with a buy limit of 2,000, and its in-game description marks it as an alpha-only listing that will be removed in a future update when a natural source is added.
Planting herb seeds for Herblore
Every herb action in Farming consumes 2 seeds and harvests 100 herbs for Herblore potions, starting with Penril Herb at level 5 for 47 XP, Sourweed Herb at level 15 for 86 XP, Mantalyme Herb at level 25 for 133 XP, and Nomel Herb at level 35 for 185 XP. The upper half of the herb patch runs from Oxilyme Herb at Farming level 50 for 392 XP and Sporlyle Herb at level 65 for 686 XP to Larx Herb at level 75 for 882 XP and Barrentoe Herb at level 90 for 1,180 XP.


