Early money in Melvor Idle 2 comes from adding one processing step before you sell, because a Copper Bar sells for more than the Copper Ore it came from. Keep the Stone, logs, Coal and Flax that later recipes need, clear the Hobgolbin Camp, and put the first gold into tools and bank slots.
Smelting and smithing the first ores
Copper Ore sells for 3 GP and the Copper Bar sells for 7 GP, so smelting at Smithing level 5 more than doubles the price of the ore. Iron Ore sells for 6 GP and an Iron Bar for 12 GP, while Silver Ore sells for 10 GP and a Silver Bar for 24 GP. A Steel Bar needs one Iron Ore and one Coal at Smithing level 25 and sells for 29 GP. Gold Ore opens at Mining level 38 and sells for 16 GP, and the Gold Bar from Smithing level 38 sells for 42 GP.
The Stone you mine from level 1 can be smithed too, since a Stone Platebody takes 5 Stone, needs Smithing level 5 and sells for 41 GP, while a single Stone sells for 2 GP. Bars sell for less than the gear made from them: at Smithing level 12 a Copper Platebody takes 5 Copper Bars and sells for 127 GP, and at level 35 a Steel Platebody takes 5 Steel Bars and sells for 325 GP. The smithing calculator lists every recipe with its sell value.
| Action | Level | XP | Time | XP / h | GP / h | Products & Inputs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stone | 1 | 3 | — | — | — | |
Clay | 3 | 4 | — | — | — | |
Copper Ore | 5 | 6 | — | — | — | |
Rune Essence | 8 | 5 | — | — | — | |
Stone Debris | 10 | 25 | — | — | — | |
Iron Ore | 10 | 10 | — | — | — | |
Topaz Vein | 12 | 29 | — | — | — | |
Sulfur | 18 | 13 | — | — | — | |
Silver Ore | 18 | 12 | — | — | — | |
Coal | 25 | 10 | — | — | — | |
Fallen Star | 30 | 13 | — | — | — | |
Sapphire Vein | 32 | 46 | — | — | — | |
Mithril Ore | 35 | 22 | — | — | — | |
Gold Ore | 38 | 20 | — | — | — |
Gems, jewellery and Stardust
The Topaz Vein opens at Mining level 12 and gives Uncut Topaz, which sells for 20 GP, and Crafting cuts it into a Topaz that sells for 29 GP. The Sapphire Vein opens at level 32, and Uncut Sapphire sells for 36 GP against 54 GP once it is cut. The bigger gain is jewellery, because a Silver Topaz Amulet needs Crafting level 18, 2 Silver Bars and 1 Topaz and sells for 226 GP. Gold does not beat silver here, since a Gold Topaz Amulet from Crafting level 38 sells for only 210 GP. The Locked Thug Chest drops Silver Bars and Uncut Topaz, so it can feed these recipes without any mining.
Stardust sells for 17 GP but is the extra input of the Astral jewellery, and an Astral Silver Topaz Amulet sells for 276 GP. The Astrologer at Thieving level 36 has Stardust in its common loot, 3 to 6 at a time.
Fishing and cooking
Calm Shallows and Pebble Bank both pay in two ways: a weighted catch that you sell, and a small chance of a special catch. Calm Shallows at level 6 catches Raw Sardine and Raw Shrimp, and its special catch is a Pearl Clam with a 0.5% chance that sells for 817 GP. Pebble Bank at level 23 has the same 0.5% chance of a Rusty Ancient Dagger, which sells for 3,267 GP.
Cooking raises the price of the main catches: Raw Trout sells for 42 GP and Trout for 66 GP, while Raw Salmon sells for 65 GP and Salmon for 103 GP. Pier Walk at level 32 adds Raw Pike, which sells for 65 GP, and a cooked Pike sells for 99 GP. Rapid Runs at level 39 catches Raw Salmon and Raw Trout, and Cooking Salmon opens at level 39 as well. Trout cooks from the level of Pebble Bank and Pike from the level of Pier Walk, so each of those catches and its recipe open together. The fishing calculator lists the interval of every spot.
| Action | Level | XP | Time | XP / h | GP / h | Products & Inputs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Shallow Pools | 1 | 8 | 6.0s | 4,800 XP | 0 GP | |
Calm Shallows | 6 | 13 | 8.0s | 5,850 XP | 0 GP | |
Quiet Bend | 12 | 17 | 9.0s | 6,800 XP | 0 GP | |
Dock Waters | 18 | 25 | 11.0s | 8,182 XP | 0 GP | |
Pebble Bank | 23 | 35 | 12.0s | 10,500 XP | 0 GP | |
Windswept Shores | 27 | 16 | 6.0s | 9,600 XP | 0 GP | |
Pier Walk | 32 | 42 | 12.0s | 12,600 XP | 0 GP | |
Moonlit Stream | 35 | 22 | 9.0s | 8,800 XP | 0 GP | |
Rapid Runs | 39 | 54 | 13.0s | 14,954 XP | 0 GP |
Woodcutting, Flax and Fletching
A Normal Log sells for 3 GP, an Oak Log for 6 GP, a Willow Log for 17 GP and a Teak Log for 25 GP. Fletching turns them into bows: an Oak Bow from level 15 takes 2 Oak Logs and a Bowstring and sells for 48 GP, and a Willow Bow from level 30 takes 2 Willow Logs and a Bowstring and sells for 85 GP. The Bowstring comes from Flax, because the Flax Bush at Woodcutting level 5 gives Flax and Crafting turns one Flax into one Bowstring. A crossbow needs a smithed head as well, so an Iron Crossbow from Fletching level 13 takes 3 Oak Logs, an Iron Crossbow Head and a Bowstring and sells for 124 GP. The Teak Tree opens at Woodcutting level 35, and a Mithril Crossbow at Fletching level 39 takes 3 Teak Logs and sells for 388 GP.
| Action | Level | XP | Time | XP / h | GP / h | Products & Inputs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Normal Tree | 1 | 3 | 3.0s | 3,600 XP | 3,600 GP | |
Flax Bush | 5 | 3 | 2.0s | 5,400 XP | 1,800 GP | |
Oak Tree | 5 | 8 | 4.0s | 7,200 XP | 5,400 GP | |
Wood Debris | 10 | 50 | 30.0s | 6,000 XP | 7,200 GP | |
Ambervine Bush | 20 | 4 | 2.0s | 7,200 XP | 5,400 GP | |
Fortress Wall | 25 | 42 | 50.0s | 3,024 XP | 24,480 GP | |
Damaged Fortress Wall | 25 | 42 | 50.0s | 3,024 XP | 24,480 GP | |
Willow Tree | 25 | 17 | 5.0s | 12,240 XP | 12,240 GP | |
Treant Remains | 30 | 50 | 12.0s | 15,000 XP | 300 GP | |
Teak Tree | 35 | 22 | 6.0s | 13,200 XP | 15,000 GP | |
Fort Gate | 39 | 59 | 100.0s | 2,124 XP | 27,000 GP |
Thieving’s first targets
Thieving pays in items, not Gold Pieces, so a target is worth whatever its loot sells for. The Citizen at level 1 drops only Stone and Bread, worth 2 GP and 5 GP, so use it for levels. The Thug at level 5 is the first real step, because its common loot includes leather armour and Rope and its rare table gives 5 to 10 Silver Bars. The Locked Thug Chest at level 10 takes 8 seconds and drops 5 to 10 Uncut Topaz as common loot, plus 3 Silver Bars. The Thug Chief at level 15 drops copper armour, and its Copper Platebody sells for 127 GP.
The Cooking Stall at level 12 drops Cake Base, Sweet Dough and Sushi Base, the bases that Strawberry Cake, Banana Pancake and Trout Sushi are cooked from. The Fisherman at level 20 drops raw fish, up to 5 Raw Pike on its common table, and Raw Salmon on its rare table. The Chef at level 30 drops finished food, and a Strawberry Cake sells for 338 GP while a Chicken Sandwich sells for 168 GP.
| Action | Level | XP | Time | XP / h | GP / h | Products & Inputs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Citizen | 1 | 7 | — | — | — | |
Thug | 5 | 9 | — | — | — | |
Locked Thug Chest | 10 | 38 | — | — | — | |
Cooking Stall | 12 | 10 | — | — | — | |
Thug Chief | 15 | 13 | — | — | — | |
Craftsman | 17 | 14 | — | — | — | |
Fisherman | 20 | 17 | — | — | — | |
Farmer | 25 | 19 | — | — | — | |
Wizard Scholar | 28 | 20 | — | — | — | |
Chef | 30 | 22 | — | — | — | |
Capital Guard | 32 | 17 | — | — | — | |
Locked Ranchers Chest | 33 | 74 | — | — | — | |
Bandit | 33 | 22 | — | — | — | |
Market Seed Stall | 35 | 20 | — | — | — | |
Astrologer | 36 | 25 | — | — | — |
The Hobgolbin Camp reward
The Hobgolbin Camp opens once you have killed 15 Hobgolbin, and each clear pays 100 GP and a Hobgolbin Chest. The Hobgolbin Chest sells for 400 GP, and the camp is an Easy dungeon that ends with Ghelbak, the Hob Chief. Ten clears of the Hobgolbin Camp unlock the first +50 Bank Slots purchase, which costs 25,000 GP. The second combat bank purchase asks for ten clears of the Harvest Farm and costs 50,000 GP, and each clear pays 150 GP and a Harvest Farm Chest. The Harvest Farm is an Intermediate dungeon that opens after 20 kills of Jack O Lantern, so check your gear in the combat simulator before you try it.
First tools and bank slots
Every gathering skill sells its first tool at level 5, and the Copper Axe, Copper Pickaxe and Copper Fishing Rod each cost 2,000 GP and 25 Copper Bars. The second tier at level 10 is a big jump, because an Iron Pickaxe costs 15,000 GP and 50 Iron Bars. The Steel Fishing Rod at level 25 costs 50,000 GP and 100 Steel Bars, and the Mithril Fishing Rod at level 35 costs 100,000 GP and 150 Mithril Bars. Each tier needs the one before it, so no tier can be skipped.
| Upgrade | Category | Cost | Requirements | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bank Slots | 5,000 GoldPieces | Level 20 Fishing | ||
| Bank Slots | 25,000 GoldPieces | Level 50 Fishing | ||
| Bank Slots | 250,000 GoldPieces | Level 85 Fishing | ||
| Fishing | 2,000 GoldPieces + 25 Copper Bar | Level 5 Fishing | ||
| Fishing | 15,000 GoldPieces + 50 Iron Bar | Level 10 Fishing Requires previous tier | ||
| Fishing | 50,000 GoldPieces + 100 Steel Bar | Level 25 Fishing Requires previous tier | ||
| Fishing | 100,000 GoldPieces + 150 Mithril Bar | Level 35 Fishing Requires previous tier | ||
| Fishing | 250,000 GoldPieces + 200 Adamantite Bar | Level 45 Fishing Requires previous tier |
The cheaper side purchases come at the same time: a Copper Axe Head costs 1,000 GP and 15 Copper Bars and adds a 2% chance of double damage against trees and bushes. The Copper Pickaxe Head costs the same and raises the rock break chance of ore veins by 25%, and the Copper Reel cuts the maximum fishing interval by 1 second. The Wooden Axe Handle skips the bars, since it costs 1,000 GP and 25 Normal Logs and adds a 1% Output Doubling chance in Woodcutting. Bank space comes next: a +20 Bank Slots upgrade costs 5,000 GP and unlocks at level 20 of the skill that sells it, as Woodcutting, Fishing and Thieving do. The +25 Bank Slots upgrade needs level 50 and costs 25,000 GP, so it falls outside this range.
What not to sell
Keep Stone until the quest Stone Arrows are made, because Pointy Preparation asks you to hand in 24 of them and Stone Arrowtips cost 2 Stone for a batch of 10. Stone is also an ingredient of the Basic Snare, the Pebble Sling and the Stoner’s Pickaxe, which asks for 100 of it. Coal opens at Mining level 25 and sells for 5 GP, yet a Steel Bar needs 1 of it, a Mithril Bar needs 2 and a Steel Rock Anchor needs 20. A Willow Log sells for 17 GP, but the Reinforced Woodcutter’s Axe takes 25 of them, a Canyon Support takes 10 and the Willow Axe Handle from the shop takes 45. Normal Logs and Oak Logs are shop inputs in the same way, since Fletching Station I takes 50 Normal Logs and the Oak Axe Handle takes 35 Oak Logs. Flax sells for 1 GP and Rope for 5 GP, but Flax becomes Bowstring and String, and the Wrapped Axe Binding in the shop takes 50 Rope. Read the full list of uses on an item page, such as the one for Stone, before you sell a stack of anything you cannot yet process. The money making guide covers the levels above 40, and the beginners guide covers the first quest and the tool order, while the shop guide lists every purchase and the money making ranking compares live rates.



